What You’ll Learn
- What 4 famous CEO transitions reveal about trusting the market's first reaction
- How a multi-fund portfolio holding roughly 4,000 stocks can still be undiversified
- 3 simple checks to run before making any changes to your portfolio
About This Episode
On November 12th, Nvidia's stock fell 14% shortly after the opening bell.
Its co-founder and longtime CEO had abruptly resigned, with no successor in place.
Even if you've never owned a share directly, Nvidia still makes up about 6% of the S&P 500, so it sits inside many of the index funds retirement savers rely on.
But a sudden leadership change is a risk few investors see coming, and one the market doesn't reliably pay you to take.
And when your nest egg needs to last 30+ years, it's worth knowing how much of it depends on one company, one industry, or one headline.
In this episode, I'm exploring which risks the market rewards and why some popular places to seek shelter may not be what they seem.
You can't predict which company will make headlines next, but you can control how much your retirement depends on the outcome.
When You’re Ready, Here Are 3 Ways I Can Help You:
- Schedule a Free Retirement Strategy Session. Get your questions answered + learn how we can help you improve retirement success and lower taxes.
- Listen to the Stay Wealthy Retirement Show. An Apple Top 50 investing podcast.
- Join My Retirement Newsletter. Weekly retirement and investing tips (delivered to our inbox!)
+ Episode Resources
- What a 50% Tech Drop Would Really Cost (Stay Wealthy Newsletter)
- Nvidia Has Lost $2 Trillion in Value Since Its October Peak (CNBC)
- Nvidia’s Fiscal 2026 Form 10-K: The Risk of Losing Key Executives (SEC)
- CEO Shakeups: What History Tells Investors (Charles Schwab)
- Mercer Advisors: When Nvidia Drops, 3 Reasons to Pause Before You Act
- Jason Zweig: The Stock Market’s Bargain Bin Is Secretly Stuffed With AI Stocks (WSJ)
- Episode 225: Small Cap Value (Part 1): Is This Popular Strategy Dead?
- Episode 227: Small Cap Value (Part 3): How to Choose the Right Fund and Take Action
- Episode 306: Why the S&P 500 Isn’t Enough Once You Retire (And 5 Tax-Smart Steps to Diversify)
+ Episode Transcript
On Thursday morning, November 12th, Nvidia shares dropped 14% shortly after the opening bell.
Its co-founder and longtime CEO, Jensen Huang, had abruptly resigned following reports of an affair and growing concerns about national security.
The stock did recover much of that initial drop, finishing the day down 4%. But since it peaked on October 6th, Nvidia is down 35% and has lost nearly $2 trillion in market value.
Now, if you don’t own Nvidia stock directly, this might sound like someone else’s problem. But here’s what makes it relevant to your retirement:
Even after experiencing double-digit losses, Nvidia still represents about 6% of the S&P 500 today. So, if you own an S&P 500 or broad-based U.S. stock fund, you own a slice of Nvidia, too.
Which raises two important questions. How much of your retirement savings is exposed to risks nobody can predict? And which of those risks are you actually being compensated for taking?
In today’s episode, we’ll look at what history tells us about stocks after the departure of other high-profile CEOs, why some asset classes that appear to offer shelter from uncertainty may not be what they seem, and three practical checks to help you assess the risks in your own portfolio.
Welcome to another episode of the Stay Wealthy Retirement Show. I’m your host, Taylor Schulte, and every week I cover the most important financial topics to help you “stay wealthy” in retirement. Ok, onto today’s episode.
Nvidia’s CEO Exit and the Risk You’re Not Paid to Take in Retirement
In early October, Nvidia’s stock reached an all-time high after a remarkable run. But by the end of the month, trouble was beginning to surface.
More specifically, on October 29th, reports emerged about Jensen Huang’s relationship with a Chinese businesswoman suspected by U.S. intelligence officials of spying for Beijing.
Then, on November 5th, just two days after the midterms, Nvidia and other major tech stocks like Google, Broadcom, and Oracle led a broad market selloff, driven largely by fears that the election results could lead to tighter regulations on AI and slower growth.
A few days later, Huang publicly acknowledged having an affair, and on November 12th, he resigned as Nvidia’s CEO and stepped down from its board.
The company’s longtime chief financial officer, Colette Kress, was named interim CEO while the board began searching for a permanent replacement. By then, Nvidia’s stock had fallen roughly 30% from its early October peak.
So, in just over a month, investors were confronting two very different sources of uncertainty: the political and regulatory outlook for AI, and the sudden departure of the man who had led the world’s most valuable company for more than three decades.
And to really appreciate just how significant that departure was, consider what Huang helped build. In 1993, he co-founded Nvidia with two fellow engineers after meeting at a Denny’s in San Jose. Over the next 33 years, he helped transform that idea into a company worth more than $5 trillion.
And here’s a pretty remarkable statistic about that growth: It took Nvidia 30 years to reach its first trillion dollars in market value. It then added another $4 trillion in just 29 months.
As Ray Kroc, the founder of McDonald’s, once said, “I was an overnight success all right, but thirty years is a long, long night.”
Now, there’s one detail about this situation that I think is particularly worth highlighting.
Like most publicly traded companies, Nvidia publishes an extensive list of potential risks in its annual report. Those disclosures cover everything from product defects and export restrictions to the possibility of losing key executives.
In other words, the company had explicitly warned investors about the risk of losing an important leader.
But identifying a risk is very different from predicting how, when, or why it might happen.
So, I think it’s safe to say that a scandal involving an alleged Chinese spy, national-security concerns, alleged affairs with two other employees, and the abrupt resignation of Nvidia’s founder after 33 years of building one of the most valuable companies in the world wasn’t on anyone’s 2026 bingo card.
That’s what makes company-specific risks so difficult to manage. Even with extensive research and financial disclosures, unexpected events can dramatically change a company’s outlook almost overnight.
For retirement investors, it’s another reminder of why broad (and prudent) diversification matters. You can’t eliminate these surprises, but you can limit how much your financial future depends on the fortunes of any one company or sector.
Now, while the circumstances surrounding Jensen Huang’s departure were highly unusual, other major companies have experienced unexpected leadership changes, too.
And when we look at how their stocks performed afterward, the range of outcomes is pretty revealing.
What History Says Happens After a CEO Leaves
To put those different outcomes into perspective, let’s quickly walk through four notable CEO transitions highlighted in a recent analysis from Charles Schwab.
What’s interesting about these examples is not just how differently they unfolded, but also how little the initial market reaction told investors about what would happen next.
And we’ll start with Apple, where even a carefully planned transition was still unsettling for investors in the beginning.
Case Study #1: Steve Jobs to Tim Cook (2011)
When Steve Jobs stepped down as Apple’s CEO in 2011, investors knew exactly who would replace him. Tim Cook had spent years working alongside Jobs and was already running much of Apple’s day-to-day operations.
Yet even with that preparation and public knowledge, Apple’s stock initially fell about 5% in after-hours trading following the announcement.
By the next day, however, shares rebounded and were down less than 1%.
And what happened afterward is pretty remarkable. Under Cook’s leadership, which ended earlier this year, Apple’s market value increased by more than 1,000%. In other words, that initial selloff told investors remarkably little about Apple’s long-term prospects under its new leader.
Case Study #2: Steve Ballmer to Satya Nadella (2014)
Microsoft offers a different example. From 2000 to 2014, the company was led by Steve Ballmer, who you might remember from this iconic moment on stage at a Microsoft event:
[PLAY BALLMER CLIP: “Developers! Developers! Developers!”]
Now, Satya Nadella, a longtime Microsoft employee, might not have brought quite the same energy and enthusiasm to the stage, but he did replace Ballmer as CEO in 2014.
And initially, Wall Street’s reaction was relatively muted. But what investors couldn’t have known at the time was how dramatically Nadella would reshape the company.
As just a few examples, he accelerated Microsoft’s shift toward cloud computing, he made the controversial decision to make its software available on competing platforms, and eventually, he helped position the company as a major player in the artificial intelligence space.
Since taking over from Ballmer, Microsoft’s market value has grown from roughly $300 billion to nearly $4 trillion dollars. In other words, one of the most successful leadership transitions in recent corporate history barely registered with investors when it was announced.
Case Study #3: Mark Hurd to Léo Apotheker at HP (2010)
Of course, not every leadership change turns out so well. And Hewlett-Packard’s experience in 2010 offers perhaps the closest historical comparison to Nvidia’s current situation.
At the time, Mark Hurd was one of Silicon Valley’s most respected executives. But in August 2010, he was forced to resign after an investigation revealed that he had falsified expense reports to conceal a personal relationship with a contractor.
In response, HP hired an outsider, Léo ah-poh-TAY-ker, to replace him. And within months, ah-poh-TAY-ker was proposing major changes to HP’s business, including potentially spinning off its enormous personal computer division.
He lasted less than a year, but, by the time he departed in September 2011, HP’s stock had fallen roughly 45% from the end of 2010.
Eventually, the stock recovered and by 2015, shares were trading about 28% above their level when Hurd was forced out. But I think it’s interesting and helpful to point out here that HP’s problems extended well beyond the original scandal.
The decisions made under its new leadership created another set of challenges for shareholders that few, if any, could have predicted.
Case Study #4: Warren Buffett to Greg Abel (2026)
And finally, consider one of the most anticipated leadership transitions in corporate history.
For years, Berkshire Hathaway investors knew Greg Abel would eventually succeed Warren Buffett. So, when Buffett announced in 2025 that Abel would officially take over at the beginning of 2026, there was little mystery about who would lead the company.
Despite having that transparency and information, Berkshire’s stock still struggled following the announcement, trailing the broader market for months as investors questioned whether the company could maintain its success without Buffett.
Eventually, shares recovered and reached new highs as investors became more interested in defensive, value-oriented companies amid uncertainty surrounding AI, growth, and tech stocks.
And that raises an important question. How much of that stock performance reflected investors’ confidence in the new CEO Greg Abel, and how much was simply the result of changing market conditions?
It’s difficult to separate the two. And with Abel having led the company for less than a year, it’s still far too early to judge the long-term outcome.
What These 4 Case Studies Tell Us
So, what can we learn from these four examples?
At Apple, an initially nervous market reaction was followed by extraordinary growth. At Microsoft, investors barely reacted to a leadership change that preceded a remarkable transformation. HP experienced a steep decline before eventually recovering, while Berkshire’s stock struggled despite having one of the most carefully planned transitions imaginable.
While these four examples aren’t enough to establish a statistical pattern, they illustrate just how difficult it is to predict what a CEO departure will mean for shareholders.
And there’s another complication worth highlighting here. A company’s stock price reflects far more than the person running the business. Its products, competitors, valuation, and broader market conditions all influence what investors ultimately earn.
And that brings us back to Nvidia. Schwab analyst Nathan Peterson recently described Nvidia’s stock as cheap while acknowledging significant uncertainty surrounding its future leadership.
And while it sounds counterintuitive, I think both things can be true. A stock can look attractively priced based on expected future earnings, but if those earnings expectations change, what looks like a bargain today might not be much of a bargain at all.
For retirement investors, the important lesson here is to recognize how much uncertainty surrounds any company’s future. We can’t predict how Nvidia’s next CEO will perform or how its stock will respond, but we can control how much of our nest egg depends on those outcomes.
Because there’s a big difference between taking risks that can help grow your retirement savings and taking risks that may offer nothing in return.
The Risk You’re Paid to Take, and the One You’re Not
To understand that difference, it helps to separate investment risk into two broad categories.
The first is known as company-specific risk. A CEO resigns. A lawsuit is filed. A product fails, or a regulator steps in. Events like these can hit a single company hard while barely touching the rest of the market.
Mercer’s CIO made this point well last week, explaining that, because company-specific risk can be reduced through diversification, investors are not reliably compensated for taking it.
Said another way, the market does not pay you extra for putting a large portion of your retirement savings into one company and hoping things work out.
The second category includes risks that have historically been associated with higher expected returns.
Longtime listeners might remember way back in episode 225, where I explained the four key drivers of investment returns identified by financial researchers.
As a quick refresher, those four drivers are: owning stocks instead of bonds, investing in smaller companies over larger ones, buying stocks trading at lower relative prices (also known as value investing), and favoring companies with higher profitability. Each of those four factors have historically helped investors earn higher returns.
And while decades of market data support these findings, there’s an important catch.
Higher returns from these four drivers are never guaranteed, and they don’t arrive on a predictable schedule. In fact, these investments can underperform for years at a time, which is why capturing their potential long-term benefits requires patience, discipline, and the conviction to stick with them when they’re out of favor.
And this distinction becomes especially important in retirement. When you’re regularly withdrawing money to cover living expenses, a large, unexpected loss in a concentrated investment can be particularly damaging, especially if you need to sell shares before they’ve had a chance to recover
Now, you might be thinking that company-specific risk isn’t much of a concern if you own mutual funds and ETFs instead of individual stocks.
And in many cases, you’d be right. But there’s a common misconception worth quickly addressing: owning more funds does not necessarily mean you’re getting more diversification.
For example, imagine dividing your investments equally among four widely popular funds: the Fidelity Contrafund, Vanguard Total Stock Market, the Growth Fund of America, and the Nasdaq-100 ETF, QQQ.
Between them, you’d have exposure to around 4,000 individual companies.
On the surface, that sounds like a well-diversified portfolio. But take a closer look at what those funds actually own, and you might be surprised
Despite holding thousands of stocks through these funds, roughly 40% of your money would still be concentrated in the same 10 or so companies.
That’s because these funds have similar investment policies and own many of the same businesses. So, when you combine them, you end up owning some of those companies several times over, often without realizing it.
This is how investors can unknowingly take on more company-specific risk than they intended. Even with dozens of funds spread across different accounts and maybe even different custodians, a significant portion of their retirement savings might still depend on the performance of a relatively small group of companies, often within the same industry.
Which is why I always encourage investors to look beyond the number of funds they own and pay attention to how their money is actually spread across different companies, industries, sectors, and countries inside those funds.
It’s also worth noting that a great company does not always make a great investment, particularly over shorter periods of time. The price you pay, and the expectations already built into that price, matter a great deal too.
Consider what’s happened this year. As of mid-November, analysts expected the Magnificent 7—the seven largest tech companies in the S&P 500—to grow their earnings, or profits, by roughly 55% in 2026 compared with the previous year. For the other 493 companies in the index, expected profit growth was only about 26%.
But those percentages simply reflect how much the companies are expected to grow their profits, not how much investors have earned from owning their stocks.
In fact, through mid-November, the Mag 7 stocks have gained just 3% this year, compared with a 13% gain for the other 493 stocks in the S&P 500 index.
How is that? How can companies who are expected to grow their profits so much faster deliver lower stock returns?
Well, stock prices reflect what investors expect a company to earn in the future. And when those expectations are already extremely high, even impressive business results might not be enough to push the stock price higher.
Meanwhile, companies attracting far less attention can deliver better investment returns simply by exceeding more modest expectations.
It’s a useful reminder that investing in the fastest-growing companies does not guarantee you’ll earn the highest returns.
Now, does any of this mean you should avoid Nvidia or other tech-focused companies? Of course not. A globally diversified stock portfolio will give you exposure to the Magnificent 7 and many others. But what you own and how much you own matters, and the recent events at Nvidia offer a good reminder to take a closer look at your investments and the risks you’re actually exposed to.
So, as you think about your own retirement plan, one question I’d encourage you to ask yourself is: “How much of my financial future depends on risks I’m not being paid to take?”
Why Small-Cap Value Isn’t an AI Hedge
And once you start looking more closely at the risks in your portfolio, it’s natural to wonder whether other parts of the market might offer some protection from the uncertainty surrounding AI and technology stocks.
For many investors recently, that means turning to or considering value stocks. And while that may seem like a reasonable approach, there’s something important to understand about how value stocks are classified.
Last week, Wall Street Journal columnist Jason Zweig published a fascinating article explaining how some of the biggest winners from the AI boom have actually been labeled as value stocks.
For example, two companies benefiting from surging AI demand, Micron and SanDisk, spent the first half of this year in the Russell 1000 Value Index, despite their stock prices climbing more than 300% and 800%, respectively.
How is that possible?
Well, many value indexes rely heavily on something called the price-to-book ratio, which compares a company’s stock price to its book value. In plain English, this ratio essentially compares what the company owns minus what it owes.
And because many chipmakers often invest heavily in factories and equipment, those assets increase their book value, making their stocks look cheaper, even when they might look expensive by other measures.
So, just because a fund has the word “value” in its name doesn’t necessarily mean you’re avoiding AI or high-flying growth stocks or truly buying companies at attractive prices.
A good example is the difference between two popular small-cap value ETFs: Vanguard’s VBR and Avantis’s AVUV.
Both target the same general part of the market and are categorized as small value funds, but they take very different approaches.
For example, VBR tracks a broad small-cap value index and charges just 0.05% per year. AVUV, on the other hand, costs five times as much, at 0.25%, and uses a more targeted approach that favors smaller companies trading at lower relative prices with stronger profitability.
And here’s what’s interesting.
Through November 16th, AVUV has returned roughly 20% this year, compared with 17% for VBR. And over the last five years, AVUV has outperformed VBR by roughly 11%.
Of course, that doesn’t guarantee the Avantis fund will continue outperforming, and it doesn’t prove that paying a higher fee will always produce better results.
It does, however, illustrate an important point. Yes, keeping investment costs low is incredibly important and vital to long-term investing success. But what a fund actually owns, and how those investments are selected, can be equally important.
At my firm, that’s one reason we use systematic value strategies constructed and managed by fund companies like Avantis and Dimensional Funds in client portfolios. We’re far more interested in those underlying investment characteristics than whether a particular holding happens to be associated with AI, technology, or any other popular theme.
But here’s where I want to offer an important caution.
Over a century of academic data supports the case for small-cap value investing, and I firmly believe it deserves a meaningful place in a diversified retirement portfolio. However, it should not be viewed as a short-term bet against AI or volatile tech stocks or a safe place to hide from the next market downturn.
As Zweig points out in his article, even though value stocks have historically outperformed growth stocks over long periods of time, that advantage can disappear for years or even decades.
In fact, from 2008 through 2025, large U.S. value stocks underperformed large growth stocks by roughly three percentage points per year. And while those figures are for large companies, the broader lesson applies to small-cap value investing, too.
We have no reliable way of predicting when these investments will outperform. And shifting into them because you’re worried about other parts of the market is really just another form of market timing.
Which is why I agree with Zweig’s larger message. If you already own a prudent, broadly diversified portfolio that fits your retirement needs, goals, and risk tolerance, reacting to the latest headlines will do more harm than good.
The diversification you hold should be something you build on purpose and expect to maintain for years, not a trade you place this month because of a headline.
What to Do (and Not Do) This Month
So, rather than trying to predict where Nvidia or other struggling tech stocks go from here, or searching for a short-term hedge in light of recent events, I’d suggest three simple checks to ensure you’re making smart decisions to protect your retirement plan.
Check #1: Pause Before You Act
The first check is to avoid making major investment decisions in the middle of uncertainty. To pause before you act
A representative at Mercer recently described situations like Nvidia’s as the “fog of war” for a single company. Stock prices can swing dramatically in both directions as new information emerges, and there’s often more that investors don’t know than what they do
That doesn’t mean you should ignore what’s happening. But before making changes, take some time to evaluate whether the news actually affects your long-term investment strategy.
Check #2: Add Up Your Largest Holdings Across Every Account
The second check is to take a closer look at how much of your retirement savings is concentrated in a handful of companies.
Remember, owning a stock through several different mutual funds or ETFs doesn’t make that exposure disappear.
In last week’s Stay Wealthy newsletter, I walked through the numbers for a $1 million portfolio and showed how dramatically exposure to the largest U.S. companies can differ between an all-S&P 500 portfolio and a globally diversified one.
So, look across all your accounts, including your IRAs, current and former 401(k)s, your spouse’s accounts, and any individual stocks you’ve accumulated over the years.
The goal is to understand how much of your financial future depends on the performance of just a few businesses.
Check #3: Read the Holdings, Not the Label
Finally, the third check is to take a look under the hood of the funds you own, especially any value or dividend-focused funds.
Review their largest holdings and consider how the underlying stocks are valued. Measures like price-to-earnings and price-to-book can help, and you can usually find this information for free on the funds website or Morningstar.com. You can also contact your advisor or the fund company directly to learn more about their portfolio construction methodology.
As we saw earlier, two funds with nearly identical names can own very different investments.
And if your review reveals that you’ve become more concentrated than intended, consider whether it’s time to rebalance.
As I discussed last month, you may be able to make necessary adjustments inside your retirement accounts without triggering capital gains taxes. You can also use planned withdrawals to gradually reduce positions that have grown too large, rather than creating unnecessary taxable gains elsewhere.
Bottom Line
Ok, let’s bring this back to where we started. On November 12th, Nvidia lost 14% of its value shortly after the opening bell.
And the catalyst wasn’t disappointing earnings, a recession, or some major change in the company’s products. It was an unexpected leadership crisis that few, if any, investors could have anticipated.
And that’s what makes this story such a valuable reminder, especially for those of us planning for retirement.
We can spend countless hours studying companies, evaluating investments, and trying to anticipate what might happen next. But there will always be risks we can’t see coming, no matter how much research we do.
Which is why I believe some of the most important investment decisions are the ones we make long before the next surprise arrives.
Decisions about how much risk we’re willing to take, where we’re taking it, and whether our portfolio is diversified enough to support our long-term goals through periods of uncertainty.
So I’ll leave you with one question worth considering. If any single company in your portfolio lost a third of its value next month, would that force you to change your retirement plans?
If the answer is yes, that’s worth examining before the next unexpected headline arrives. And if the answer is no, you’re in a much better position to stay focused on your long-term plan and let the headlines come and go.
Thank you, as always, for listening. To view the extensive research and resources supporting today’s episode, just head over to youstaywealthy.com/312.




